• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
collis & griffor logo
CALL TODAY734-827-1337
  • About
    • Stuart M. Collis
    • Beverly M. Griffor
    • Andrew C. Hendra
    • Our Firm
    • Testimonials
  • Practice Areas
    • Business Law
    • Criminal Law
    • Family Law
    • Probate & Estate Planning
    • Copyrights & Trademarks
    • Commercial & Consumer Collections
  • Make a Payment
  • Blog
  • Contact

Michigan Supreme Court Decides People v Slaughter

July 1, 2011 by Collis & Griffor PC

The Michigan Supreme Court today has ruled that the community caretaking exception to the Fourth Amendment against warrantless searches and seizures applies to a firefighter answering a 911 call. The prior rulings of the Court had never directly spoken on this issue, which has let the lower courts to their own devises for determining the applicability of this doctrine to many first responders, including fire fighters. The caretaking exception recognizes that :

“local police officers . . . frequently investigate vehicle accidents in which there is no claim of criminal liability and engage in what, for want of a better term, may be described as community caretaking functions, totally
divorced from the detection, investigation, or acquisition of evidence relating to the violation of a criminal statute.” Cady v Dombrowski, 413 US 433, 441.

With the ruling in Slaughter, firefighters are added to the list of those persons who can serve through their work, the role of community caretakers. This does not mean that now it is possible for a firefighter to barge into your living room uninvited. The actions of the fire fighter still has to be a reasonable action related to the caretaking function. If the action fails to meet one of those two requirements, then it is not a permitted action.

The opinion in Slaughter is careful to remind that this is only one of many exceptions to the warrant requirement based on this law enforcement role. Other situations where it may apply include “entering an apartment to remove a former girlfriend following a domestic dispute, removing an intoxicated person from the street, entering an abandoned boat to ascertain ownership and the safety of the mariners, responding to a missing vehicle complaint, searching an unconscious person for identification, and responding to persons likely to be in need of emergency aid.

Categories: Uncategorized

Primary Sidebar

Get Solid Legal Advice Today

* indicates required information

I have read the disclaimer*

Disclaimer

Get Solid Legal Advice Today

* indicates required information

I have read the disclaimer*

Disclaimer

Footer

Contact

Collis & Griffor PC  logo Collis & Griffor PC

1851 Washtenaw Rd.
Ypsilanti, MI 48197

Tel: 734-827-1337
Fax: 866-827-1738

Driving Directions
Google Rating
3.9
Collis & Griffor, PC
Collis & Griffor, PC
3.9
Michael Bowerman
Michael Bowerman
17:09 13 Apr 17
I have used Stewart Collis on three separate occasions over the past 10+ years, two concerning animals and once for family law. In all three cases, Stewart has been prompt, courteous and understanding of my concerns. I would recommend him to anyone looking for advice or representation.
johnny Irwin
johnny Irwin
17:06 16 Jan 17
I am a business owner and Collis and Griffor PC was extremely helpful in setting up my LLC and other business documents. They worked very closely with me to make sure I understood exactly what I needed. I have consulted with them at every turn, and I appreciate the personal touches. I would highly recommend this firm to everyone with legal needs. Collis and Griffor PC is the best firm out there!
Calvin Hopkins
Calvin Hopkins
16:00 16 Jan 17
Terribly unprofessional and rude. He asked for us to talk to him like he is dumb. Saying "I'm not a dumb person, I just like to ask dumb questions." When we expressed how we felt he was condescending in his approach we were promptly asked to leave. Like the other reviewer says take your business elsewhere.
Douglas Stearns
Douglas Stearns
16:13 14 Dec 16
Went through this firm to attempt to help a friend. Basically charged me thousands of dollars to tell me in the end that they couldnt help me with my legal problem. Roughly four thousand dollars and did absolutley nothing. Got taken to the cleaners. Take my advice and your business else where.
Josh Duncan
Josh Duncan
17:10 16 Jan 17
Highly recommend! Friendly staff and knowledgeable attorneys.
See All Reviews
powered by Google

Memberships

association of family and conciliation courts
Collis & Griffor PC © 2019. All rights reserved. | Disclaimer | Privacy Policy | Sitemap